The Best Long Island Wedding Catering

Long Island Wedding CaterersCatering a wedding offers an opportunity for brides and grooms to truly personalize the affair. So do use this as a way to create a one-of-a-kind reception.

For example, you can customize the catering menu to coordinate fully with your honeymoon location. Heading to Mexico? Serve an elegant menu that reflects that particular cuisine. Or if you each come from different ethnic backgrounds — you’re Italian, he’s Greek — blend the catering menu to reflect that. Are you an eco-conscious couple? Hire a green caterer that will only utilize organic, local produce.

Here on Long Island, it’s easy to find a catering company that can mesh with your palate and tastes. Take a look but we want your comments about these too, to help other brides. So please comment below.

Art of Eating

When you reminisce about a great wedding, it’s the food you remember most. Dazzle your guests with delicious savory dishes from Chef Cheryl Stair. Art of Eating also helps select the right venue, from a rustic barn to a magnificent garden where every nuance of your day is elegantly arranged and prepared.


Manhattan-based Chefs Bjorn and C.J. Kitsos-Holm cater throughout the tri-state area with mouthwatering meals. As an integral part of the wedding team, they work with you to create specific menus, including dishes for guests who might have food allergies.

Christopher Michael
PO Box 614
Laurel, New York, 11948 |

Jamesport caterers since 1993, they provide inclusive packages from top quality staff, site rental, tenting, bar service and floral design with buffet or French style food service. Choose from a raw bar, grilling pasta station or food-themed stations to add pizzazz to your wedding.

Corinne’s Catering
845 East Jericho Turnpike
Huntington Station, NY 11746

From cozy at-home gatherings to large weddings, Corinne’s fleet of mobile kitchens and build-your-own menu capacity will fulfill whatever you desire. They’ve handled many special occasions such as fundraisers for Hillary Rodham Clinton and launch parties like Chris Rock’s HBO special. Let them take your day from routine to unique and special. It’s all in the presentation.

Culinary Studio
136 Wall St.
Huntington, NY 11743

The Culinary Studio caters to your every need, offering an array of seasonal split-plate options like: Roasted Filet Mignon, Pecan Crusted Halibut and choice of succulent Hors D’Oeuvres such as mini Crab cakes, Coconut Shrimp and Grilled Baby Lamb chops.

The Raging Skillet
335 E. Houston St., New York, NY 10002

Self proclaimed “wildest catering company this side of the Mason-Dixon line,” Chef Rossi has been written up in magazines such as New York and Self for fresh, all natural cuisine. The Raging Skillet specializes in non-traditional parties with a personalized touch. Staff dressed in kilts? Or mini-skirts? Specialty dishes include: Salmon Tandoori with Cucumber Chutney and Basmati Rice Pilaf or Yellow Snapper in Catalana sauce with Vegetable Paella or Plantain crusted Red Fish.

Seafood Shop Catering
Wainscott, New York 11963

Selected as one of the best caterers on Long Island for off-premise catering, engagement parties and weddings, The Seafood Shop prides themselves on delectable food. Check out their website for beach-themed galas in their casual-elegant style including their famous Punch Bar.

Seasons Distinctive Catering
2191 3rd Avenue
New York, NY 10035

Chefs Marc Tessitore and Robert Zimmerman spent more than a decade honing their craft with New York City’s finest. Since 2001, Seasons Distinctive Catering provides full-service catering with scrumptious food and beverages, including staff and rentals. They’re well known in the industry and offer main courses such as Seared Tuna with Taro chips or Miso crusted Sea Bass in Yuzu Vinaigrette, satisfying even the most discerning taste.

Thyme and Again
129 Noyac Rd
Southampton NY, 11968

From Montauk to Manhattan, this full-service caterer combines local flavor for succulent dishes with tailor-made catering and event planning at your beck and call. They work within your budget to suit your taste and needs for a grand Thyme.

Back to Long Island Wedding Planners’ Best Picks