The Best Long Island Wedding Cakes

We asked our wedding planners to select their favorite wedding bakeries on Long Island. Here’s a list of their top picks, based on the overall quality and reliability of their work.

long island wedding cakesIn addition to providing top-notch, custom-made wedding cakes, you can also look to these wedding bakeries for unique reception favors, as well as desserts for the wedding rehearsal dinner, the bridal shower, or even bachelor and bachelorette parties.

Here are our wedding planners’ sweetest selections, but we want to hear from you too.  Please leave a comment below so other brides can read what you have to say about these.

Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods
229 Montauk Highway
West Sayville, NY 11796

A division of Lovin’ Oven Celebrations, Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods bakes up pastries, desserts and delicious cakes that gained rave reviews for their elegant style and scrumptious taste.  They can even recreate your most outlandish dream fantasy cake.

Cheryl Kleinman Cakes
448 Atlantic Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217-1704

Gourmet Gourmet Patisserie
407 Fort Salonga Rd
Northport, NY 11768

Have Your Cake, Ltd.
152 Jessup Ave
Quogue, NY 11959

Impressive, delectable cakes in ribbons of colorful, swirling sugary frostings: White Chocolate Buttercream, Chocolate Ganache, Hazelnut Mousse, Key Lime, and Cannolis.  You name it. They can bake it. 

La Bonne Boulangerie
125 West Broadway
Port Jefferson, NY 11777

For all your catering needs, La Bonne Boulangerie takes the worry out of your special day providing everything from rentals and staff for the event.  Gourmet cooks create specialty foods and talented pastry chefs craft European tortes, desserts, artisan and rustic breads and more. 

Michele Brown Baking
244 Glen Cove Avenue, Suite H
Glen Cove, NY 11542

Sacred Sweets

An artists’ palette of imaginative, delicious cakes, confections and chocolate gifts that tempt even the most discerning taste, Sacred Sweets adds the perfect touch to your special occasion.  Homemade sweet biscotti, short breads and delectable handmade treats like Mexican chocolates use the finest cocoa beans, alcohols, cream, butter, honey and fruits.

Sugar Sugar
77 Main Street
Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
631-288-2947 or

Whether it’s whimsical or sophisticated, Sugar Sugar captures your personality in cakes and sweets.  Using the best ingredients and finding that right blend of texture, color and taste, cakes can be enhanced with blown sugar, crystallized petals or fresh flowers to replicate bridal bouquets.   They also create specialty candy and cookies—great for reception favors.

Back to Long Island Wedding Planners’ Best Picks